Choosing the Right Appraiser: A Guide for Agents, Attorneys, Accountants, and Homeowners

A Guide to Selecting the Right Appraiser

Selecting a real estate appraiser is a crucial decision that can significantly impact your financial transactions and investments. Whether you’re a homeowner looking to make improvements, an agent who needs a pre-listing appraisal, or an attorney or accountant who requires a certified appraisal, a well-qualified and experienced appraiser is essential for accurate property valuation. In this guide I put together, I’ll share the key factors to consider when hiring a real estate appraiser in the Birmingham, Alabama area or wherever you live to help you make an informed and confident choice.

Choosing the Right Appraiser A Guide for Agents, Attorneys, Accountants, and Homeowners

1. Certification and Licensing

Appraisal standards and regulations are vital to maintaining the integrity of the profession. It’s imperative to choose an appraiser who is certified and licensed in the state they appraise in. This ensures that the appraiser has undergone rigorous training, meets the state’s education requirements, and follows ethical guidelines in their practice. A licensed appraiser demonstrates commitment and accountability to their clients and the industry.

2. Experience and Expertise

While education and licensing are essential, experience is a critical factor in assessing an appraiser’s competence. Look for an appraiser who has a substantial track record of working in the area where the property to be appraised is located. Experienced appraisers possess an innate understanding of local market dynamics, neighborhood nuances, and property value trends, leading to more accurate valuations.

Appraisers with diverse experience in evaluating different types of properties, such as residential, condominium, vacant land, rural, luxury homes, and manufactured home are equipped to handle a wide range of appraisal assignments, catering to various client needs.

3. Specialization in your specific market

Real estate markets, like the Birmingham area I work in, can be multifaceted, with each neighborhood having its unique characteristics. To obtain precise and reliable appraisals, consider hiring an appraiser who specializes in the area your home is located in. Local specialists are intimately familiar with factors that influence property values, such as school districts, proximity to amenities, and local economic trends.

A specialized appraiser is more likely to recognize the hidden value in a property that might be overlooked by someone who lacks local knowledge, thus providing you with a more accurate representation of the property’s true worth.

4. Education and Qualifications

Beyond the basic licensing requirements, top-tier appraisers often pursue additional education and professional designations to enhance their skills and knowledge. Look for appraisers who hold designations such as the SRA (Senior Residential Appraiser from The Appraisal Institute). These designations are granted by reputable organizations and signify a higher level of expertise and commitment to the appraisal profession.

Engaging an appraiser with advanced qualifications ensures that you are working with someone who is up-to-date with industry best practices and possesses a deeper understanding of complex appraisal scenarios.

5. Knowledge of Appraisal Methods

Property valuation involves a meticulous process that encompasses various appraisal methods. The sales comparison approach, income approach, and cost approach are the three primary methods appraisers use to determine property value. Each method is suited for specific property types and market conditions.

A skilled appraiser should be adept at applying these methods effectively, using them in conjunction when necessary, to arrive at the most accurate and comprehensive appraisal results possible.

6. Strong Ethical Standards

Ethics are the foundation of any reputable profession, and real estate appraisal is no exception. Trustworthy appraisers uphold the highest ethical standards, maintaining objectivity and impartiality in their work. They should avoid any conflicts of interest that could compromise the integrity of the appraisal process.

To ensure ethical practices, look for appraisers who comply with the Uniform Standards of Professional Appraisal Practice (USPAP), a set of guidelines established by the Appraisal Standards Board. The USPAP outlines the ethical and professional standards that all appraisers must follow, protecting both clients and the industry.

7. Communication Skills

Effective communication is vital in any client-service provider relationship, and it holds particular significance in the appraisal process. A competent appraiser should possess excellent communication skills, enabling them to explain complex appraisal concepts and methodologies in simple terms.

Whether you are a homeowner seeking the market value of your home for personal reasons or an agent who requires a pre-listing appraisal, a proficient appraiser should be able to communicate their findings clearly and address any questions or concerns you may have.

You should look for someone who has the heart of a teacher so that they want to help you learn about the process.

8. Technology Adoption

In the fast-paced world of real estate, technology plays an increasingly significant role in streamlining appraisal processes and enhancing accuracy. Look for appraisers who utilize modern tools and technologies to complement their expertise.

Appraisers who utilize technology in their jobs can more easily collect and analyze data and study market trends, leading to more precise and data-driven valuations.

9. Strong Market Knowledge

A successful real estate appraiser should stay well-informed about the latest trends and developments in their real estate market. They should have access to a wealth of data sources and maintain up-to-date information about property sales, economic conditions, and demographic shifts.

Appraisers with strong market knowledge can provide valuable insights and recommendations to clients, guiding them in making informed decisions regarding real estate transactions.

10. Client Reviews and Testimonials

To gain a better understanding of an appraiser’s reputation and service quality, take the time to read client reviews and testimonials. Online platforms and the appraiser’s website may feature feedback from past clients, providing valuable insights into their experiences.

Positive reviews and testimonials can give you added confidence in the appraiser’s abilities and reliability, helping you make a well-informed decision.

11. Licensed Appraiser vs. Property Data Collector

In the real estate industry, there are distinct differences between a fully licensed appraiser and a property data collector. Understanding these distinctions is crucial when selecting an appraiser for your property valuation needs in Birmingham, Alabama are or wherever your property is located.

Licensed Appraiser:

A licensed appraiser is a professional who has undergone the necessary education, training, and testing required by the state Real Estate Appraisers Board. They hold a valid license that permits them to perform real estate appraisals in compliance with state and federal regulations. Licensed appraisers are well-versed in various appraisal methodologies and possess the knowledge and experience needed to provide accurate property valuations.

Licensed appraisers are qualified to appraise all types of real estate, including residential, commercial, industrial, and vacant land. They have a deep understanding of the local real estate market and can factor in multiple variables to determine a property’s true value.

When hiring a licensed appraiser, you can expect a comprehensive and unbiased appraisal report that adheres to professional standards, including the Uniform Standards of Professional Appraisal Practice (USPAP).

Property Data Collector:

A property data collector, on the other hand, is an individual who gathers information about a property, such as its physical characteristics, size, and condition. They may work for various entities, including real estate agencies or data collection firms. While they play a role in gathering essential data for appraisals, they lack the qualifications and expertise to perform full-fledged property valuations.

Property data collectors do not possess a valid appraiser’s license, and they are not authorized to provide formal appraisals that can be used for legal or lending purposes. Their responsibilities primarily revolve around collecting data that will be used by licensed appraisers in their valuation process.

Key Differences:

The primary differences between a licensed appraiser and a property data collector lie in their qualifications, scope of work, and the authority to provide official appraisals:

Qualifications: A licensed appraiser has met stringent educational and experience requirements set forth by their local appraiser’s board. They have passed the necessary exams and obtained a valid license. Conversely, a property data collector usually has no eal estate knowledge and only the necessary skills to collect data for use by a certified appraiser.

Scope of Work: A licensed appraiser is authorized to conduct a thorough analysis of a property’s value using various appraisal methods, considering factors such as comparable sales, income potential, and replacement cost. On the other hand, a property data collector’s role is limited to gathering basic property information and data, which is then used by the appraiser in their valuation process.

Appraisal Authority: Only a certified appraiser can provide an official appraisal report that is legally valid for lending institutions, tax assessment purposes, and legal proceedings. A property data collector’s findings are not recognized as formal appraisals and cannot be relied upon for crucial financial decisions.

Why Hire a Licensed Appraiser?

Choosing a fully licensed and certified appraiser offers numerous benefits and ensures the credibility and accuracy of the property valuation. A certified appraiser’s expertise and adherence to professional standards guarantee that you receive a reliable and unbiased appraisal report.

When working with a licensed appraiser, you can have confidence in their ability to understand complex valuation scenarios, consider all relevant factors, and provide a comprehensive assessment of the property’s worth. Their valuations are recognized by lenders, government agencies, and other relevant stakeholders, instilling trust in the appraisal process.


Choosing the right real estate appraiser in the Birmingham, Alabama area or your specific market involves careful consideration of their certification, experience, expertise, and ethical standards. A specialized and well-qualified appraiser with strong market knowledge and effective communication skills can provide you with accurate valuations and invaluable insights into the local real estate market. By prioritizing these essential traits, you can confidently select an appraiser who will meet your specific needs and ensure an accurate and non-biased appraisal for whatever reason you have.

If you have any other questions about choosing the right appraiser, feel free to contact me. As always, thanks for reading.

If you liked this post subscribe by email (or RSS feed).


  1. Kathlee Morris says

    Thank you for this information.
    A question we have is this; We are doing remodeling, and basic home repairs to update our
    home in hopes the near future will be more promising , the interest rates decreased for a refi.
    Can we hire a appraiser when we are ready independently from the lending institutions choice,
    first ? We have had problems with unfair appraisers in the past. We wondered what is in it for them
    to deliberately give a appraisal that is not fair and much lower than it should be? We have had some real shysters in the past years here in Michigan. We suspect the state of Michigan has some shady
    agendas for doing this? We were former Whistle Blowers to state fraud and corruption and we
    suspect they have never stopped targeting us as retaliation. Michigan is a very corrupt state especially now.

    • Kathlee, you can indeed hire your own appraiser to get a market value appraisal. If you do this before you go to the bank keep in mind that the bank will most likely not accept your appraisal because they have to order it and the appraiser usually has to be on their approved appraiser list. If you tell the bank that you recently got an appraisal to help you make some financial decisions they may retain the appraiser to do a new appraisal but don’t count on it. At the very least, if the bank does another appraisal within a reasonable time frame of the one you have done you can provide the new appraiser with the sales that were used for their consideration. I would offer them the addresses and let them know that they were used in a recent appraisal. They will then analyze them and may use them in their report. Of course if any other sales have occurred since the first appraisal they will be considered as well. Good luck.

  2. Very thorough, Tom. I like this piece. It’s wild that you have to parse the difference between a property data collector and appraiser, but welcome to 2023. Great stuff here.

    • Thanks, Ryan. I think people need to know the difference between a PDC (property data collector) and an appraiser because it does not appear that they are being told this by some lenders or even the PDC. The public needs to know that they are getting something less than a full interior inspection by the appraiser. Unless the PDC has the same education, knowledge, and experience that an appraiser does they may miss a critical piece of information that could be critical in the appraisal. What’s bad is that the appraiser must sign off that they trust the information and believe it to be accurate and reliable which it may not be. Caveat Emptor-buyer beware.

  3. Great article Tom! Property Data Collectors will be one of the topics I plan to discuss this weekend on our local Radio show as their guest. People need to realize that PDC’s are not anywhere in the same ball park as Certified/Licensed Appraisers. The public is the last to know the whole truth about how lenders/ Fannie and Freddie are trying to replace Appraisers with PDC’s and AVM’s, VALUE ACCEPTANCE programs or Hybrid style reporting. The Public/borrowers are the ones who will suffer the most by the use of alternate methods of valuation on the most expensive purchase / loans of their lives. I plan to SHARE this one. Thanks again!

    • Thanks, Mary. I’m glad to know other appraisers like yourself are educating the public about this. Anyone that gets an appraisal should know what type of product they are paying for, however, I don’t think most know that the person visiting their house may not be the appraiser. The property data collector may not have the experience and knowledge to observe all of the important information that an experienced and licensed appraiser would. Good luck on the radio show.

Speak Your Mind


Sign up and get valuable content!

  • Get local real estate market data
  • Learn valuable information from a seasoned appraiser
  • Find out what adds value to your home

I respect your privacy. Your information stays with me.

Call Now Button